Left-Rothbardianism: Difference between revisions
no edit summary
mNo edit summary |
No edit summary Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit |
||
| (20 intermediate revisions by 11 users not shown) | |||
Line 1:
{{Ideology
|title
|image
|aliases
[[File:Left-Voluntaryism.png]] Left-Voluntaryism<br>▼
Left-Anarcho-Capitalism<br>
▲[[File:Left-Voluntaryism.png]]
Left-Voluntaryism<br>[[File:Markliberate.png]] Synthesis Market Anarchism<br>▼
[[File:Ancapcom.png]] Anarcho-Capitalist Communism<br>▼
Progressive Stage-Rothbard<br>
|alignments=
[[File:Libunity-yellow.png|link=:Category:Libertarian Unity]] [[:Category:Libertarian Unity|
[[File:
{{Info|Anarchists}}<br>
{{Info|Libertarians}}<br>
[[File:Syncretic.png|link=:Category:Syncretic]] [[:Category:Syncretic|{{Color|#F9BBBB|'''Sy'''}}{{Color|#93DAF8|'''nc'''}}{{Color|#C8E4BC|'''re'''}}{{Color|#F5F4AB|'''tic'''}}]]
|song=
|theorists
*[[File:Glibr.png]] [[Green Libertarianism|Karl Hess]] (1923-1994)
*[[File:Murray N Rothbard.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Murray N. Rothbard]] (1926-1995)
*[[File:Bhl.png]] [[Bleeding-Heart Libertarianism|Roderick T. Long]] (1964-)
|themecolor
|textcolor
|influences=
[[File:Ancap-1.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism]]
[[File:
|caption=
'''Left-Rothbardianism''', also called '''Left-Voluntarism''', is an economically centre-right, anarchist and culturally ambiguous ideology that is the child of [[File:Anmark2.png]] [[Left-Wing Market Anarchism|Left-wing Market Anarchism]] and [[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism]].▼
}}
{{Quote|
quote="Socioeconomic equality and legal equality both fall short of the radicalism of Lockean equality. For neither of those forms of equality calls into question the authority of those who administer the legal system. … Both forms of equality call upon that power structure to do certain things; but in so doing, they both assume, and indeed require, an inequality in authority between those who administer the legal framework and everybody else."
|speaker=[[File:Bhl.png]] [[Bleeding-Heart Libertarianism|Roderick T. Long]]
}}
▲'''Left-Rothbardianism''', also called '''Left-
The principle as a whole states that property can only be legitimately owned by 2 means, direct trade from the past owner or applying your labor to un-owned land, and it uses this principle to found its claim on the confiscation of "private" property,<ref>[https://www.panarchy.org/rothbard/confiscation.html Confiscation and the Homestead Principle by Murray Rothbard (1969)] Panarchy.org</ref> specifically the part where it states that applying your labor to un-owned property (
The difference between the [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Classical homesteading principle]] and the [[File:Property.png]][[Propertarianism|Neo-Lockean principle]] is that the first one also accepts the Lockean proviso as legitimate, which states that the homesteading principle only applies as long as there is enough and of the same quality for everybody else, while the Neo-Lockean principle rejects this proviso.▼
Despite the [[File:Soc-h.png]] [[Socialism|Left-]] prefix of the name this ideology, which could make some people think this is a socialist ideology, it heavily advocates for the respect of private property<ref>Lora, Ronald; Longton, Henry (1999). ''The Conservative Press in Twentieth-Century America''. Greenwood Press. p. 369.</ref> as a natural right that derives from the right of self-ownership, but they don't see property as legitimate if its a derivative of coercion, which includes, if the property derives from [[File:Corp.png]] [[Corporatocracy|state benefits]].
==Beliefs==▼
It is a synthesis of [[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Rothbardian Anarcho-Capitalism]] and [[File:Anmark2.png]] [[Left-Wing Market Anarchism|Left-Market Anarchism]], that is, adopting Leftist rhetoric and applying certain principles ([[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|The Lockean Homestead Principle]], for example) to create concepts agreeable to said left sector while still maintaining an Anarcho-Capitalist framework and advocating for the exact same society.▼
It also supports workers cooperatives as a viable option for the disbandance of the state (As stated before).▼
▲The difference between the [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Classical homesteading principle]] and the [[File:
They oppose the common consensus that [[File:Regulationism.png]] [[Regulationism|government regulation]] helps to eliminate or mitigate oppression by big corporations, saying that furthermore the state is the source of the problem it says to solve.
Line 41 ⟶ 47:
It believes that these corporations which were benefited from the state with more or less largesse should be allowed to be seized by their workers or third parties to eliminate state benefits to companies.<ref name="A">[https://www.panarchy.org/rothbard/confiscation.html Confiscation and the Homestead Principle by Murray Rothbard (1969)] Panarchy.org</ref>
▲==Beliefs==
▲It is a synthesis of [[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Rothbardian Anarcho-Capitalism]] and [[File:Anmark2.png]] [[Left-Wing Market Anarchism|Left-Market Anarchism]], that is, adopting Leftist rhetoric and applying certain principles ([[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|The Lockean Homestead Principle]], for example) to create concepts agreeable to said left sector while still maintaining an Anarcho-Capitalist framework and advocating for the exact same society.
▲It also supports workers cooperatives as a viable option for the disbandance of the state (As stated before).
===Cases of legitimate confiscation of property===
Line 53 ⟶ 55:
==History==
This ideology, similar to [[File:Paleolib.png]] [[Paleolibertarianism]], which was a synthesis made by Rothbard with [[File:Plcn2.png]] [[Paleoconservatism|Paleoconservatives]], is a synthesis of the works done by Rothbard along with [[File:Anmark2.png]] [[Left-Wing Market Anarchism|Left-Market Libertarians and Anarchists]], such as [[w:Ronald_Radosh|Ronald Radosh]]<ref>Rothbard; Murray; Radosh, Ronald, eds. (1972). ''A New History of Leviathan: Essays on the Rise of the American Corporate State''. New York: Dutton.</ref> and [[w:Karl_Hess|Karl Hess]].<ref>Hess, Karl (1975). ''Dear America''. New York: Morrow.</ref> This alliance with these Left-Market Anarchists (Ronald Radosh having even been a Marxist) was due to Rothbard having long embraced a reading of American history that emphasized the role of elite privilege in shaping legal and political institutions, this, of course, was naturally agreeable to many on the left which and came increasingly handy in the 1960s to seek alliances with them. This alliance with this left sector layed the path of modern Left Market Anarchism<ref>[https://mises.org/library/rothbards-left-and-right-forty-years-later Long, Roderick T. (4 August 2006). "Rothbard's 'Left and Right': Forty Years Later". Rothbard Memorial Lecture, Austrian Scholars Conference 2006. Mises Institute. Retrieved 10 January 2020.]</ref> and also was used to strengthen ties with other Libertarian sectors. Eventually, though, Rothbard broke with the left and ended up allying with the growing [[File:Plcn2.png]] [[Paleoconservatism|Paleoconservative movement]], as stated before.<ref>Doherty, Brian (2007). ''Radicals for Capitalism: A Freewheeling History of the Modern American Libertarian Movement''. New York: Public Affairs. pp. 562–565.</ref><ref>Raimondo, Justin (2001). ''An Enemy of the State: The Life of Murray N. Rothbard''. Amherst, New York: Prometheus. pp. 277–278.</ref>
==Personality==
Line 70 ⟶ 72:
{{Flag-auto
|c1
|h1
|c2
|h2
|c3
|h3
}}
Line 83 ⟶ 85:
*[[File:Anmark2.png]] [[Left-Wing Market Anarchism]] - Markets and anarchy!
*[[File:Mutalist.png]] [[Mutualism]] - I wish you could figure out that property isn't theft, but still, left libertarianism and anarchy!
*[[File:Bhl.png]] [[Bleeding-Heart Libertarianism]] - My more moderate friend.
*[[File:Socliber.png]] [[Social Libertarianism]] - Another moderate friend!
*[[File:Libertarian.png]] [[Libertarianism]] - Pretty good, but leftist rhetoric is quite effective, you should try it.
*[[File:Agorismf.png]] [[Agorism]] - My twin brother.
Line 89 ⟶ 93:
===Frenemies===
*[[File:Ancom.png]] [[Anarcho-Communism]] - I don't like how you dislike both property and markets but at least you're an anarchist, and your rhetoric is pretty nice.
*[[File:Dengf.png]] [[Dengism]] - A fellow capcom, but why the authoritarianism? Also, Xi Jinping is pretty awful.
*[[File:Paleolib.png]] [[Paleolibertarianism]] - Fellow Rothbard synthesis, but why would you synthesise with [[File:Plcn2.png]] [[Paleoconservatism]]? <s> Also, Rothbard joining up with the [[File:Plcn2.png]] [[Paleoconservatism|Paleocons]] meant I fell apart </s>
===Enemies===
*[[File:
*[[File:Nazi.png]] [[Nazism]] - NO
*[[File:Nazbol.png]] [[National Bolshevism]] - Unironic Nazi-Commie. You're horrible!
*[[File:Plcn2.png]] [[Paleoconservatism]] - Not cool man, I can't believe [[File:Rothbard.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Rothbard]] teamed up with you!
==Further Information==
Line 108 ⟶ 116:
*[https://oreddit.com/r/LeftVoluntaryism/ r/LeftVoluntaryism]
*[https://twitter.com/LPMarketA Libertarian Party Market Anarchist Caucus on Twitter]
==References==
Line 131 ⟶ 137:
{{Navbox/Libunity}}
{{Navbox/Anarchists}}
{{Navbox/Libertarians}}
{{Navbox/Prefixes}}
[[Category:Libertarian Left]]
[[Category:Libertarian Right]]
| |||