Jump to content

Syndicalism: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit
No edit summary
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit
 
(25 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown)
Line 2:
|themecolor=FF0000
|textcolor=fff
|title = [[File:SyndSyndieSam.png]] Syndicalism [[File:SyndieSamSynd.png]]
|image = File:SyndicalismNew.png
|caption = "Man, I wish Kaiserreich was real."
|aliases = [[File:Synd.png]] Synd<br>
[[File:Synd.png]] Syndie<br>
[[File:Fut2Synd.png]] [[Futurism]]Orthodox Syndicalism<br>
[[File:RevSynd.png]] Revolutionary Syndicalism<br>
[[File:Sorel.png]] Sorelianism<br>
[[File:SyndieSam.png]] Trade Unionism<br>
[[File:SyndieSam.png]] Labourism<br>
[[File:LibSyndieSam.png]] Liberal Laborism (some) <br>
[[File:SyndieSamChrist.png]] Christian Laborism (some) <br>
Mascot of [[File:Libsoc.png]] Libertarian Socialism<br>
{{Alias|Councom.png|Council Communism|[[File:TripartiteCorporatism.png]] [[Corporatism|Class Collaborationism]]}}<br>
{{Alias|DanielDeLeon.png|De Leonism|Slum Proletarian}}<br>
Line 20 ⟶ 21:
{{Info|Libertarian Left|Libertarian Left}}<br>
[[File:Cultcenter.png|link=:Category:Cultural Center]] [[:Category:Cultural Center|{{Color|#8BC34A|'''Cultural'''}} {{Color|#9D22B2|'''Center'''}}]] (in general)<br>
[[File:Rfrm.png|link=:Category:Cultural Center]] [[:Category:Cultural Center|{{InfoColor|#9D22B2|'''Culturally Center-Left'''}}]] (most)<br>
{{Info|Socialists}}<br>
[[File:Synd.png|link=:Category:Syndicalists]] [[:Category:Syndicalists|{{Color|#FF0000|'''Syndicalists'''}}]]<br>
{{Info|Communists}}(some)<br>
[[File:Internat.png|link=:Category:Internationalists]] [[:Category:Internationalists|{{Color|#782F52|'''Internationalists'''}}]] (many)<br>
[[File:LeftBert.png|link=:Category:Libertarians]] [[:Category:Libertarians|{{Color|#FF0000|'''Libertarians'''}}]]<br>
|influences =
Line 34 ⟶ 36:
[[File:AnSynd.png]] [[Anarcho-Syndicalism]]<br>
[[File:Boric.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism|Boricism]]<br>
[[File:CorptismFut2.png]] [[CorporatismFuturism]] ([[File:Sorel.png]] Sorelianism)<br>
[[File:Fut2.png]] [[Futurism]]<br>
[[File:GeoSynd.png]] [[Geosyndicalism]]<br>
[[File:Gramsci.png]] [[Neo-Marxism|Gramscianism]] ([[File:Sorel.png]] Sorelianism)<br>
[[File:Greensynd.png]] [[Green Syndicalism]]<br>
[[File:Newman.png]] [[Post-Anarchism|Lacanian Anarchism]] ([[File:Sorel.png]] Sorelianism)<br>
[[File:MariateguismLpop.png]] [[MariateguismLeft-Wing Populism]]<br>
[[File:Mao.png]] [[Maoism]] ([[File:Sorel.png]] Sorelianism, alleged)<ref>The Italian right believed that Mao was merely using Marxism-Leninism as a cover, and that the real ideas lay in the mythological violence of the Cultural Revolution and the Platonic and Spartan ideals of popular unity and asceticism.</ref><br>
[[File:Mariateguism.png]] [[Mariateguism]]<br>
[[File:Mariateguism.png]] [[Mariateguism]] ([[File:Sorel.png]] Sorelianism)<br>
[[File:Sorelia.png]] [[National Syndicalism]]<br>
[[File:Pron.png]] [[Peronism]]<br>
[[File:Sansepolcrismo.png]] [[Fascism|Sansepolcrismo]]<br>
[[File:Yellsoc.png]] [[Yellow Socialism]]<br>
|sub =
[[File:Sorel.png]] '''Sorelianism''' {{Collapse|
Line 61 ⟶ 64:
*[[File:Mutalist.png]] [[Mutualism]]
*[[File:Natsynd.png]] [[National Syndicalism]] (erroneously)
*[[File:Labriola.png]] [[Neo-Marxism|Antonio Labriola ThoughtLabriolianism]]
*[[File:Nietzsche.png]] {{PHB|Nietzscheanism}}
*[[File:DepressionMale.png]] {{PHB|Schopenhauerism|Philosophical Pessimism}}
Line 85 ⟶ 88:
[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=za_cMos886g Aos Fuzilados da CSN]<br>
[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=14JcfSkl2XM&t=52s La Lega]
|theorists=
|theorists= *[[File:Sorel.png]] [[Anarcho-Syndicalism|Georges Sorel]] (1847-1922) [[File:Cball-France.png]] France
*[[File:KeirHardieSorel.png]] [[Democratic SocialismAnarcho-Syndicalism|KeirGeorges HardieSorel]] (18561847-19151922) [[File:Cball-UKFrance.png]] UK{{PBW|Franceball|France}}
*[[File:AnSyndKeirHardie.png]] [[Anarcho-Syndicalism|WilliamClassical DudleySocial HaywoodDemocracy|Keir Hardie]] (18691856-19281915) [[File:Cball-USUK.png]] USA{{PBW|UKball|UK}}
*[[File:AnSynd.png]] [[Anarcho-Syndicalism|RudolfWilliam RockerDudley Haywood]] (18731869-19581928) [[File:Cball-GermanyUS.png]] Germany{{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:French_FascismAnSynd.png]] [[French FascismAnarcho-Syndicalism|HubertRudolf LagardelleRocker]] (18741873-1958) (early on) [[File:Cball-FranceGermany.png]] France{{PBW|Germanyball|Germany}}
*[[File:BerthFrench_Fascism.png]] [[Mutualism|Édouard]]French [[National SyndicalismFascism|BerthHubert Lagardelle]] (18751874-19391958) (early on) [[File:Cball-France.png]] {{PBW|Franceball|France}}
*[[File:NatsyndBerth.png]] [[Mutualism|Édouard]] [[National Syndicalism|Georges ValoisBerth]] (18781875-19441939) [[File:Cball-France.png]] {{PBW|Franceball|France}}
|theorists= *[[File:SorelNatsynd.png]] [[Anarcho-National Syndicalism|Georges SorelValois]] (18471878-19221944) [[File:Cball-France.png]] {{PBW|Franceball|France}}
*[[File:MaoHair.png]] [[Maoism|Mao Zedong]] (1893-1976) [[File:Cball-China.png]] China (alleged)
*[[File:AnSynd.png]] [[Anarcho-Syndicalism|Clotario Blest]] (1899-1990) [[File:Cball-Chile.png]] {{PBW|Chileball|Chile}}
*[[File:Scargill.png]] [[Conservative Socialism|Arthur Scargill]] (1938-) [[File:Cball-UK.png]] {{PBW|UKball|UK}}
|likes=
[[File:Soc-h.png]] The Proletariat<br>
Line 144 ⟶ 149:
===[[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism|Syndicalism]] versus [[File:Councom.png]] [[Council Communism]]===
 
These two ideologies may appear very similar ofoff the bat, and they mostly are, but have a few key differences. First of all, council communism is scientific while syndicalism tends, not guaranteed, to be [[Utopian Socialism|utopic]] (in a Marxist sense). The second key difference is that syndicalism wants unions to own businesses while council communism wants worker -elected councils/boards. This might seem small but in reality, it can be quite a huge difference, as in [[File:Councom.png]] [[Council Communism]] all workers get to vote for the council while in [[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism|Syndicalism]] only unionized employees can vote. A third key difference is that [[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism|Syndicalism]] may, and often does, support decentralized rule akin to anarchism while [[File:Councom.png]] [[Council Communism]] supports the very idea of further centralisationcentralization of the proletarian state.
 
===[[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism|Syndicalism]] versus [[File:Guildsoc.png]] [[Guild Socialism|Guild Socialism]]===
 
[[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism|Syndicalism]] and [[File:Guildsoc.png]] [[Guild Socialism|Guild Socialism]] also bear a lot of similarities but differ in that [[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism|syndicates and unions]] are worker -representative bodies for specific companies while guilds are worker -owned organizations that represent entire industries in specific municipalities. [[File:Guildsoc.png]] [[Guild Socialism|Guild Socialism]] has no specific civic or governmental stance. While [[File:Synd.png]] syndicates operate within a market economy (usually) but with worker ownership of workplaces, [[File:Guildsoc.png]] [[Guild Socialism|guild socialism]] on the other hand, allocates resources and needs to their workers directly.
 
===[[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism]] versus [[File:Deleon.png]] [[De Leonism]]===
 
At first, these systems might seem quite similar, especially with both sharing the common label of [[File:Soc-h.png]] [[Socialism|Unionism]]. However, looking closer, there are some striking differences between the two. Firstly, [[File:Deleon.png]] [[De Leonism]], just like [[File:Councom.png]] [[Council Communism|council communism]], is [[File:ScientificSoc.png]] [[Marxism|scientific]], while [[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism|syndicalism]] tends to be [[File:Utsoc.png]] [[Utopian Socialism|utopian]]. Secondly, [[File:Deleon.png]] [[De Leonism|De Leonists]] support [[File:Socialist Industrial Unionism.png]] [[Ergatocracy|industrial unions]] elected by all workers which are tasked with decision making, which in contrast with the [[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism|syndicalist]] approach of [[File:SyndieSam.png]] [[Syndicalism|syndicates]] owning and controlling businesses. Lastly, [[File:Deleon.png]] [[De Leonism|De Leonists]] support the utilization of a [[File:Vanguardism.png]] [[Particracy|party of class-conscious proletarians]] in order to organize the proletariat into [[File:Socialist Industrial Unionism.png]] [[Ergatocracy|industrial unions]] and educate them, unlike [[File:Synd.png]] [[Syndicalism]]syndicalism which rejects the [[File:Vanguardism.png]] [[Particracy|party-form]] entirely, and in its place in order to organize the proletariat, [[File:SyndieSam.png]] [[Syndicalism|syndicates]] utilizes forms of propaganda in order to install discipline such as [[File:Sorel.png]] myths.
 
==Criticisms==
Line 167 ⟶ 172:
Syndicalism is often portrayed as a blue collar worker obsessive about unionization, significantly more than his [[File:Ormarxf.png]][[Marxism|father]], and he can often be seen attempting to persuade other leftists to organize and/or join worker's strikes, being highly concerned with the rights and demands of the workers and extremely critical of business owners and their practices. Synd also loves the HOI4 mod ''Kaiserreich'' due to his presence as a major ideology both in-universe and in the game.
 
He is often religious, but often still, socially progressive or "socially laissez-faire". However, this is not hard and fast, and many are culturally conservative too. This is exacerbated when he works in a [[File:Cultcon.png]] [[Traditionalism|culturally conservative]] area but of course, the opposite is true when he works in a [[File:Prog-u.png]] [[Progressivism|cultually progressive area]].
 
Unlike many of his leftist comrades, Synd cares very little for theory, and [[File:Armchair_Left_Communism.png]] [[italianItalian Left Communism|some]] question if he can even read. Despite this, he is generally amicable with other leftists, though he does wish they trusted more in the power of the workers.
 
==How to Draw==
Line 203 ⟶ 208:
* [[File:AnSynd.png]] [[Anarcho-Syndicalism]] - My anarchist son who continues my legacy.
* [[File:GeoSynd.png]] [[Geosyndicalism]] - A Georgist I can follow!
*[[File:Monsynd.png]] [[Monarcho-Syndicalism]] - Eh, as long as workers have power in their workplaces and you aren't absolutist, I will tolerate your monarch's existence.
* [[File:Mutalist.png]] [[Mutualism]] - Petit bourgeois, but I wouldn't exist without the influence of you and Marx.
* [[File:Marxfem.png]] [[Marxist Feminism]] - A union man has a happy life when he's got a union wife!
* [[File:Orthlen.png]] [[Leninism]] - Sorel became a great supporter of you and your revolution in the last years of his life.
* [[File:Leftpop-0.png]] [[Left-Wing Populism]] - Good Friend, Helps me Organise
 
===Frenemies===
* [[File:Indust.png]] [[Industrialism]] - What would us workers be without the factories we work in, and vice versa? But also, you need to be responsible and ensure our children have clean air to breathe.
* [[File:Natsynd.png]] [[National Syndicalism]] - Nation, tradition and authority are contentious topics between us.
*[[File:Monsynd.png]] [[Monarcho-Syndicalism]] - Same as above but with a king.
* [[File:Ancom.png]] [[Anarcho-Communism]] - You're based but I wish people would stop confusing my son for you. It’s getting old.
* [[File:Ormarxf.png]] [[Marxism]] - I like your ideas a lot, though at times you do fall into the trap of mechanistic determinism, and also the dictatorship of the proletariat just reinforces the master and slave relationship. Also, Blanquism and Positivism have decomposed you, but I will save your theory from them.
* [[File:ML.png]] [[Marxism–Leninism]] - I like your economics but centralization is awful and there's a reason the USSR decayed back into capitalism.
 
 
===Bosses===
4,923

edits

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.