Market Socialism: Difference between revisions

Help

Inline

Latest revision as of 13:37, 28 June 2024

Not to be confused with Capitalist Communism.

Market Socialism, clipped to MarkSoc, is an economically left-wing ideology that is unique as a leftist ideology in that it is one of the few that views markets as beneficial. Market Socialism was born in the 18th Century, when what would later be known as Classical Liberalism and Mutualism had their first lovechild, who was first written about in The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith.

"There is but one mode by which man can possess in perpetuity all the happiness which his nature is capable of enjoying, - that is by the union and co-operation of all for the benefit of each."
Robert Owen

MarkSoc wants widespread workers' self-management within the framework of a market economy. Each worker can either directly own their workplace or vote to elect their managers.

History

Market Socialism emerged as a response to classical liberalism, in fact, the most widely known Market-Socialist literature, the Principles of a Political Economy is a series of essays by John Stuart Mill as a direct response to the Wealth of Nations.

Conceptions

Employee Funds

The wage-earner fund was a Swedish proposal by Rudolf Meidner to transition from a social democratic economy to a market socialist one. Companies with more than 50 employees would have 20% of their profits taxed to allow the funds to buy up shares in the companies. Since the trade union representatives control those funds, collective employee ownership will be attained after two decades.

Illyrian model

Prominent economists in Yugoslavia, such as Jaroslav Vaněk and Branko Horvat, advocated for this type of Market Socialism. Workers would be the owners of their enterprises, and daily management would abide by the one worker, one vote principle. Profits from the worker co-ops will directly compensate the employees within. Each labor-managed firm will compete in open and free markets, and they may be able to form cooperative federations. It's possible to have a laissez-faire form of market socialism with this, similar to Mutualism.

Titoism/Self-governing socialism

Like the Illyrian model, workers' self-management was also implemented via worker councils. The difference was that government intervention in the economy was far-reaching. The workers didn't own the firms they worked in, or as the 1974 constitution put it, "...no one has rights of ownership over the social means of production..." Like many other Market Socialists, Titoism believed in a strong welfare state for the citizens.

Lange–Lerner theorem

There would be a market for final goods, while the state uses a central planning board to allocate the means of production. The government will set prices for capital goods by trial and error until they reach the equilibrium between supply and demand. The workers would still democratically manage the state-owned enterprises, and there would be social dividends thanks to the socially owned capital and natural resources. Despite being called "market socialism" by its founders, Lange Model was more of a market-simulated planning or a semi-planned economy.

Municipal Socialism

Municipal Socialism is a variant of Market Socialism that advocates the use of local government to further social and public ownership of utilities. It predominately hails from the UK, specifically in the city of Preston.

Stock Socialism

A variant of socialism in which social ownership of the means of production and workplace democracy is achieved via worker ownership of stocks. One proponent of a similar system was Pranab Bardhan who conceptualised a form of socialism in which workers had equal share of stocks. There is another variant of this with the transition to a socialist economy and that stage.

Personality

MarkSoc is quite disdainful of other, more radical socialists, as well as capitalists. They look down on other leftist ideologies for preventing the beneficial aspects of markets from proliferating in a socialist system, as well as looking down on rightist ones for the perceived corruption and suffering in their systems.

MarkSoc thinks they are the ultimate ideology and insists on everyone reading 1000 pages of economic theory to prove their point. They sometimes get caught up in their own self-importance, but they truly care about trying to help the workers of the world.

How to Draw

Flag of Market Socialism

Draw a ball.
Fill the ball white.
Draw at the top a red hammer.
Below that, draw two red arrows crossing each other.
Below that, draw a red star.
Add the eyes, and you're done!

Color Name		HEX	RGB
	Red	#EC1D26	236, 29, 38
	White	#FFFFFF	255, 255, 255

Relationships

Friends

Democratic Socialism - They're fellow socialists and supporters of cooperatives.
Mutualism - My more wacky influence.
Libertarian Market Socialism - My freedom-loving descendent.
Syndicalism - Workforce unionization and decentralized worker organizations? Based!
Distributism - Pretty much on the same page, but they're a little more religious than I am.
Titoism - My most successful form, but quit it with the excessive meddling in the cooperatives.
Alter-Globalism - The global south shall not be exploited!
Democracy - Worker cooperatives are great at providing you!
Yellow Socialism - A bit too reactionary social-wise, but otherwise he's cool.
Guild Socialism - Me but Medieval-inspired and organized along professional lines.
Kosyginism - If only you fully implemented the reforms.....

Frenemies

Capitalism - Sorry dude, your markets are cool, but your bosses are not. We also both like Adam Smith but for VERY different reasons.
Classical Liberalism - Same as above, I also enjoy Smith's works, but you're still a capitalist.
Liberal Socialism - Far too much economic pragmatism for my tastes.
Marxism–Leninism - I fit the official definition of "Socialism" so don't call me a fake socialist! However, Raul Castro, Tito, Kádár, and Kosygin are based, and so artels and cooperatives of Stalin era, which were banned by Khrushchev.
Austrian School - Thanks for the ECP, but your unregulated capitalism is horrific.
Social Liberalism - We share a lot of the same ideals, and we both like John Stuart Mill, but doesn't provide practical solutions.
Capitalist Communism - We both want free markets in a socialist state, but you come off as rather contradictory and not making much sense.
Dengism - You are not me! You are just state capitalism with a socialist mask! But even so, reforming the Maoist bureaucracy was based.
Anarcho-Syndicalism - I love your brother, but why do you want to get rid of the government?
Socialist Corporatism - Better than regular corporatism, but still too hierarchic.
Leninism - You understand that cooperatives are a good way to transition into socialism, which is based, I also like the New Economic Policy, but your rejection of reform is something I wouldn't like, in fact, reform is ideal in achieving socialism.
Honeckerism - Still too planned for my tea, but it's good that you took a step to embrace some market socialist ideals.
Other Wa rsaw Pact market so cialists - Similar to the above.
Juche - I like some of your economic ideas, but the totalitarianism and protectionism is cringe.
State Socialism - We are both socialists, but you should lessen your authoritarian rhetoric. A planned economy is stagnant and your tendency to be overly centralized and overly bureaucratic in dealing with economics tends to hurt the working class more than it helps them. Although we sometimes overlap, mostly in Eastern Europe.
Social Democracy - You're far from horrible in modern times, but I kinda miss when you were a lot closer to me rather than a friendlier version of him.
Social Authoritarianism - You're sometimes too moderate economically even getting close to him; but Revolutionary Government of the Armed Forces' Yugoslavia-like socialist self-management system was really based.
Nordic Model - Again, not bad, though I wish you followed through with Rudolf Meidner's ideas.
Anarcho-Communism - My brother with the same problems as with him. You seem to hate the markets, although Makhno at least applied me in Ukraine.^[2]

Enemies

Fascism - A corporatist economy is not even close to what I advocate for, especially with the class collaboration that it requires.
Neoliberalism - This is what exclusive capitalism leads to.
The Manager - No...NO!!!
Pinochetism - Exclusivist organizations and oligarchy? In THIS land? I think not!
Khrushchevism - Banning cooperatives in 1956 was the reason why the Soviet economy stagnated!
The Board of Directors - This is what he wants over the workers!
Hoxhaism - Stop calling any socialist ideologies that stray even slightly from Marxism–Leninism revisionist!
State Capitalism - Stop pretending to be me! We are opposites.
Corporatism - Same as above.
Italian Left Communism - Why do you hate me?
Libertarianism - "The freer the market, freer the people", I totally agree, but you misunderstood the quote.
Third Way - You're a kinder version of them with some of him too, but you still seem more exploitative.
Anarcho-Capitalism - The free market means no capitalism.
Corporatocracy - You put the statement "Capitalism is anti-market" truer than anyone else.
Objectivism - Free markets aren't about worshiping your boss or being greedy.
Avaritionism - GET AWAY FROM ME, YOU GODDAMN RED MARKET LOVER!!

Further Information

Literature

Principles of Political economy by John Stuart Mill
Chapters on Socialism by John Stuart Mill
On the Economic Theory of Socialism by Oskar Lange
Market, State, and Community: Theoretical Foundations of Market Socialism by David Miller
Why Market Socialism?: Voices from Dissent by Frank Roosevelt, David Belkin, and Robert L. Heilbroner
After Capitalism by David Schweickart
Democracy at Work: A Cure for Capitalism by Richard D. Wolff
Private Government: How Employers Rule Our Lives (and Why We Don't Talk about It) by Elizabeth Anderson

Online Communities

Wikipedia

People

Videos

Gallery

Portraits

Credit: Arksiane's drawing

Comics and Artwork

"If leftist ideologies were RPG characters" by Roxxagon, Source
"Socialist Compass" by Spade
Annoyed MarkSoc

Navigation

Notes

↑ Kádár legalized homosexuality and stopped persecution of gay people
↑ Kádár helped Khrushchev overthrow Nagy and invaded Czechslovakia.

↑ The Co-Operative Party worked extensively with New Labour both in terms of market liberalization and pushing for cooperatives in various sectors with the help of Blair and Brown.
↑ The economic system of the Makhnovshchina

[2] Kádár legalized homosexuality and stopped persecution of gay people

[3] Kádár helped Khrushchev overthrow Nagy and invaded Czechslovakia.

[1] The Co-Operative Party worked extensively with New Labour both in terms of market liberalization and pushing for cooperatives in various sectors with the help of Blair and Brown.

[4] The economic system of the Makhnovshchina

[1]

[Note 1]

[Note 2]

[2]

@@ Line 100: / Line 100: @@
 **[[File:Thar.png]] [[Anti-Authoritarianism|Anti-War Measures Act]]
 **[[File:Christsoc.png]] [[Christian Socialism]]
+**[[File:Eugen.png]] [[Eugenicism]] (Before 1944)
 **[[File:Prog-u.png]] [[Progressivism]]
 **[[File:Welf.png]] [[Welfarism]]
@@ Line 154: / Line 155: @@
 *[[File:Orthlen.png]] [[Leninism]]
 *[[File:Moderate_ML.png]] [[Marxism–Leninism|Moderate Marxism-Leninism]]
-*[[File:Social Reformism.png]] [[Reformism|Socialist Reformism]]
+*[[File:Social Reformism.png]] [[Reformism|Reformist Socialism]]
 }}
 [[File:SwedenSocDem.png]] '''Meidner Model''' {{Collapse|
@@ Line 202: / Line 203: @@
 [[File:Libms.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism|Libertarian Market Socialism]]<br>
 [[File:Minsocf.png]] [[Minarcho-Socialism|Lordon-Friot Communism]]<br>
+[[File:Anconx.png]] [[Anarcho-Conservatism|Mário Ferreira dos Santos Thought]]<br>
 [[File:Tito.png]] [[Titoism]]<br>
 }}
@@ Line 217: / Line 219: @@
 [[File:PanAmer.png]] '''Americas''' {{Collapse|
 *[[File:JohnBrown.png]] [[Abolitionism|John Brown]] (1800-1859) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
-*[[File:TommyDouglas.png]] [[Market Socialism|Tommy Douglas]] (1904-1986) [[File:Cball-Scotland.png]] Scotland/[[File:Cball-Canada.png]] {{PBW|Canadaball|Canada}}
+*[[File:TommyDouglas.png]] [[Christian Socialism|Tommy Douglas]] (1904-1986) [[File:Cball-Scotland.png]] Scotland/[[File:Cball-Canada.png]] {{PBW|Canadaball|Canada}}
 *[[File:JuanVelasco.png]] [[Social Authoritarianism|Juan Velasco Alvarado]] (1910-1977) [[File:Cball-Peru.png]] {{PBW|Peruball|Peru}}
 *[[File:RaulCastro.png]] [[National Communism|Raúl Castro]] (1931-) [[File:Castro.png]] {{PBW|Cubaball|Cuba}}
@@ Line 227: / Line 229: @@
 }}
 [[File:Cball-Commonwealth.png]] '''Commonwealth Realm''' {{Collapse|
+*[[File:Ricardosoc.png]] [[Ricardian Socialism|Charles Hall]]  (1740-1825) [[File:Cball-GB.png]] {{PBW|UKball|Great Britain}}
 *[[File:WilliamThompson.png]] [[Ricardian Socialism|William Thompson]] (1775-1833) [[File:Cball-UK.png]] {{PBW|UKball|UK}}
 *[[File:RobertOwen.png]] [[Utopian Socialism|Robert Owen]] (1771-1858) [[File:Cball-UK.png]] {{PBW|UKball|UK}}
@@ Line 335: / Line 338: @@
 *[[File:Dengf.png]] [[Dengism]] - You are not me!  You are just state capitalism with a socialist mask! But even so, reforming the Maoist bureaucracy was based.
 *[[File:AnSynd.png]] [[Anarcho-Syndicalism]] - I love your brother, but why do you want to get rid of the government?
-*[[File:Social corpratism.png]] [[Corporatism#Social Corporatism|Social Corporatism]] - Better than regular [[File:corptism.png]] corporatism, but still too hierarchic.
+*[[File:SocialistCorporatism.png]] [[Corporatism#Socialist Corporatism|Socialist Corporatism]] - Better than regular [[File:corptism.png]] corporatism, but still too hierarchic.
 *[[File:Orthlen.png]] [[Leninism]] - You understand that cooperatives are a good way to transition into socialism, which is based, I also like the [[File:NEP.png]] New Economic Policy, but your rejection of reform is something I wouldn't like, in fact, reform is ideal in achieving socialism.
 *[[File:Honecker.png]] [[Marxism–Leninism#Erich Honecker|Honeckerism]] - Still too planned for my tea, but it's good that you took a step to embrace some market socialist ideals.
-*[[File:TodorZhivkov.png]][[File:WalterUlbricht.png]] [[Marxism–Leninism|Other Warsaw Pact market socialists]] [[File:Gierek.png]][[File:Jaruzelski-2.png]] - Similar to the above.
+*[[File:TodorZhivkov.png]][[File:WalterUlbricht.png]] [[National Communism|Other Wa]][[Marxism-Leninism|rsaw Pact market so]][[National Communism|cialists]] [[File:Gierek.png]][[File:Jaruzelski-2.png]] - Similar to the above.
 *[[File:Juche.png]] [[Juche]] - I like some of your economic ideas, but the totalitarianism and protectionism is cringe.
 *[[File:Statesoc.png]] [[State Socialism]] - We are both socialists, but you should lessen your authoritarian rhetoric. A planned economy is stagnant and your tendency to be overly centralized and overly bureaucratic in dealing with economics tends to hurt the working class more than it helps them. Although we sometimes overlap, mostly in Eastern Europe.

Market Socialism: Difference between revisions

Help

Latest revision as of 13:37, 28 June 2024

Contents

History