Panarchism: Difference between revisions

From Polcompball Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Content added Content deleted
VisualWikitext
m (Replaced country names with PBW links)
 
(42 intermediate revisions by 16 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{MessageBox/Stub}}
{{Ideology
{{Ideology
|themecolor = #141414
|themecolor=#141414
|textcolor = #e7e700
|textcolor=#e7e700
|title = [[File:Panarchy.png]] Panarchism
|title=[[File:Panarchy.png]] Panarchism
|image = [[File:Pan-0.png]]
|image=[[File:Pan-0.png]]
|caption = "No this has nothing to do with pansexuality."
|caption="No this has nothing to do with pansexuality."
|aliases={{Collapse|
|aliases = Panarchy <br> [[File:Panarch.png]] Panarch <br> Free-market of voluntary governments <br> [[File:Meta-Anarchism.png]] Meta-Anarchism <br>
Panarchy<br>
[[File:Polylaw.png]] Polycentric Law <br>
[[File:Panarch.png]] Panarch<br>
Real Anarchism (by Ryan Faulk) <br>
Free-market of voluntary governments<br>
⚫
Hyper-Particularism <br>
[[File:Synthesis Market Anarchism.png]] Radical Classical Liberalism <br>
[[File:Polylaw.png]] Polycentric Law<br>
⚫
Hyper-Particularism<br>
⚫
Synthesis Voluntaryism <br>
|alignments = [[File:Libright-yellow.png]] [[LibRight]] <br>
[[File:Anlib2.png]] Anarcho-Liberalism<br>
[[File:Libertarian.png]] [[:Category:Libertarians|Libertarians]] <br>
[[File:Synthesis Market Anarchism.png]] Anarcho-Classical Liberalism<br>
[[File:Synthesis Market Anarchism.png]] Radical Classical Liberalism<br>
[[File:Awaj.png]] [[:Category:Anarchists|Anarchists]]
⚫
Synthesis Voluntaryism<br>
|definition = An ideology that believes people should have the right to chose the form of government (or no government) without having to migrate.
Progressive Conservatism On Steroids<br>
⚫
|song =
{{Alias|First Worldism.png|Alt-Right#First Worldism|Real Anarchism}}<br>
|theorists = [[File:Clib.png]] [[w:Paul Émile de Puydt|Paul Émile de Puydt]], [[File:Cball-Belgium.png]] Belgium, 1860 <br>[[File:Synthesisanarchy.png]] [[w:Max Nettlau|Max Nettlau]], [[File:Cball-Prussia.png]] Prussia, 1909<br>[[File:Egomut.png]] [[w:John Zube|John Zube]], [[File:Cball-Germany.png]] Germany, 1986<br>[[File:Volu.png]] Carl Watner, [[File:Cball-US.png]] USA, 1988<br>[[File:Panarchy.png]] Michael S. Rozeff, [[File:Cball-US.png]] USA, 2008<br>[[File:Polylaw.png]] [[w:Gustave de Molinari|Gustave de Molinari]], [[File:Cball-Belgium.png]] Belgium, 1849<br>[[File:LeftRothbardianismPix.png]] [[w:Roderick T. Long|Roderick T. Long]], [[File:Cball-US.png]] USA, 1996<br>
⚫
|likes =
⚫
|dislikes =
|variants =
⚫
*[[file:Polyarchy.png]] '''Polyarchy''' {{Collapse|
⚫
**[[File: Cosmo.png]] [[Cosmopolitanism]]<br>
}}
}}
|alignments=
⚫
|influences=[[File: Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism]]<br>
{{Info|Libertarian Right|LibRight}}<br>
{{Info|Capitalists}}<br>
{{Info|Liberals}}<br>
{{Info|Libertarians}}<br>
{{Info|Anarchists}}<br>
[[File:Right-Anarchism.png|link=Right-Anarchism (Disambiguation)]] [[Right-Anarchism (Disambiguation)|{{Color|#9425A0|'''Right-'''}}{{Color|#00AEEF|'''Wing'''}} {{Color|#FFFF00|'''Anarchists'''}}]]<br>
|influences=
⚫
[[File:Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism]]<br>
[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]]
[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]]
||influenced=[[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism]]<br>
||influenced=
[[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism]]<br>
[[File:Meta-Anarchism.png]] [[Nomadology]]<br>
[[File:Natan.png]] [[National Anarchism]]<br>
[[File:Natan.png]] [[National Anarchism]]<br>
[[File:Polyarchy.png]] [[Polyarchy]]<br>
[[File:Puzzle_Piece_Politics-Icon.png]] [[Puzzle Piece Politics]]
|school =
[[File:Puzzle_Piece_Politics-Icon.png]] [[Puzzle Piece Politics]]}}
⚫
[[File:Polyarchy.png]] '''Polyarchy''' {{Collapse|
⚫
*[[File:Cosmo.png]] [[Cosmopolitanism]]
}}
⚫
|song=
|theorists=
[[File:PanAmer.png]] '''Americas''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:Volu.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Carl Watner]] [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:Panarchy.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Michael S. Rozeff]] [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:LeftRothbardianismPix.png]] [[Left-Rothbardianism|Roderick T. Long]] (1964-) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
}}
[[File:Cball-EU.png]] '''Europe''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:Synthesis Market Anarchism.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Paul Émile de Puydt]] (1810-1891) [[File:Cball-Belgium.png]] {{PBW|Belgiumball|Belgium}}
*[[File:Polylaw.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Gustave de Molinari]] (1819-1912) [[File:Cball-Belgium.png]] {{PBW|Belgiumball|Belgium}}
*[[File:Synthesisanarchy.png]] [[Synthesis Anarchism|Max Nettlau]] (1865-1944) [[File:Cball-Prussia.png]] Prussia
*[[File:Egomut.png]] [[Anarcho-Individualism|John Zube]] (1933-) [[File:Cball-Germany.png]] {{PBW|Germanyball|Germany}}
*[[File:Svetov.png]] [[Libertarian Conservatism|Mikhail Svetov]] (1985-) [[File:Cball-Russia.png]] {{PBW|Russiaball|Russia}}
}}
⚫
|likes=
⚫
|dislikes=
}}
{{Quote|
quote="In our system there will be no more expensive balancing acts or catastrophic downfalls; no more conspiracies or usurpations. Everybody is legitimate and nobody. One remains legitimate without objection as long as one is accepted, and for one's supporters alone. Apart from this, there will be neither divine nor secular rights, no right except that to change, to perfect one's program and to make fresh appeals to one's followers."
|speaker=[[File:Synthesis Market Anarchism.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Paul Émile de Puydt]]
}}
'''Panarchism''' is an ideology that believes that the populace should have the right to choose the form of government ([[File:Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism|or lack thereof]]) that they are part of/live under without having to change their physical residence.<br>
'''Panarchism''' is an ideology that believes that the populace should have the right to choose the form of government ([[File:Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism|or lack thereof]]) that they are part of/live under without having to change their physical residence.<br>
It's the idea that every part of a certain country or group of lands should be led by voluntary associations of people and free competition of form of governments, similar to the competition of private firms on the market. People could associate and disassociate from different governments depending on their preferences.<br>De Puydt, being a [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|classical liberal]], favored [[File:Lfree.png]] Laissez-Faire economics, but Panarchism allows for different economic systems to co-exist.<br>Conflicts between people, that are part of different governments (or no government), would be handled by third-party judges and would lead to a standardization of law (like common law) among everyone as continuous conflict resolution takes place, similar to how [[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|anarcho-capitalists]] envision private law societies.
It's the idea that every part of a certain country or group of lands should be led by voluntary associations of people and free competition of form of governments, similar to the competition of private firms on the market. People could associate and disassociate from different governments depending on their preferences.<br>De Puydt, being a [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|classical liberal]], favored [[File:Lfree.png]] Laissez-Faire economics, but Panarchism allows for different economic systems to co-exist.<br>Conflicts between people, that are part of different governments (or no government), would be handled by third-party judges and would lead to a standardization of law (like common law) among everyone as continuous conflict resolution takes place, similar to how [[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|anarcho-capitalists]] envision private law societies.


== History ==
==History==
Paul E. De Puydt, the founder of Panarchism, was a Belgian writer of the 19th century. He devised Panarchism in the year 1860 with an article with the same name<ref>[http://www.panarchy.org/depuydt/1860.eng.html Panarchism] by Paul Émile de Puydt (1860)</ref> which was influenced by his ideas of free competition (result of his support for [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|free market liberalism]]) as well as his fellow Belgian economist, [[File:Anmark.png]] [[Market Anarchism|Gustave de Molinari]], who also believed the principles of free competition in the market should be expanded upon previously considered "public matters".<br>
Paul E. De Puydt, the founder of Panarchism, was a Belgian writer of the 19th century. He devised Panarchism in the year 1860 with an article with the same name<ref>[http://www.panarchy.org/depuydt/1860.eng.html Panarchism] by Paul Émile de Puydt (1860)</ref> which was influenced by his ideas of free competition (result of his support for [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|free market liberalism]]) as well as his fellow Belgian economist, [[File:Anmark.png]] [[Left-Wing Market Anarchism|Gustave de Molinari]], who also believed the principles of free competition in the market should be expanded upon previously considered "public matters".<br>
De Puydt, seeing how constant infighting over forms of government affected Europe in the 19th century, realized that it was impossible to please everyone by forcing them under a singular system, but rather the way to end these conflicts was to give everyone the chance to choose their ideal form of governance, and not interfere with that of others in a similar manner to how a [[File:Cball-Prussia.png]] Prussian citizen has no business in the governance of [[File:Cball-France-Alt.png]] France.<br>
De Puydt, seeing how constant infighting over forms of government affected Europe in the 19th century, realized that it was impossible to please everyone by forcing them under a singular system, but rather the way to end these conflicts was to give everyone the chance to choose their ideal form of governance, and not interfere with that of others in a similar manner to how a [[File:Cball-Prussia.png]] Prussian citizen has no business in the governance of [[File:Cball-France-Alt.png]] France.<br>
Though De Puydt's ideas never succeded, its influence can be seen in the writings of other [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Clasical Liberal]] writers such as [[File:Volu.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism#Voluntaryism|Auberon Herbert]], Anarchist writers such as [[File:Anin.png]] [[Anarcho-Individualism|Anselme Bellegarrigue]] and [[File:Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism|Max Nettlau]], as well as many modern [[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Anarcho-Capitalist]] thinkers, who argue that it approximated [[File:Polylaw.png]] polycentric law.
Though De Puydt's ideas never succeded, its influence can be seen in the writings of other [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Clasical Liberal]] writers such as [[File:Volu.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism#Voluntaryism|Auberon Herbert]], Anarchist writers such as [[File:Anin.png]] [[Anarcho-Individualism|Anselme Bellegarrigue]] and [[File:Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism|Max Nettlau]], as well as many modern [[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Anarcho-Capitalist]] thinkers, who argue that it approximated [[File:Polylaw.png]] polycentric law.


== Variants ==
==Variants==
=== [[File: Polyarchy.png]] Polyarchy ===
===[[File:Polyarchy.png]] Polyarchy===
[[file:Polyarchy flag.svg|thumb|{{Blacklink|Polyarchy|Flag of Polyarchy}}]]
[[File:Polyarchy flag.svg|222px|thumb|Flag of Polyarchy]]
Polyarchy is an economically variable, libertarian ideology, that strives to create a society based on [[File: Volu.png]] voluntaryism, pluralism and spatialism. To achieve this society, Gian Piero de Bellis (the founder of polyarchy) advocates for a conjunction of [[File:Cosmo.png]] [[cosmopolitanism]] and [[File:Panarchy.png]] [[panarchism]].
Polyarchy is an economically variable, libertarian ideology, that strives to create a society based on [[File:Volu.png]] voluntaryism, pluralism and spatialism. To achieve this society, Gian Piero de Bellis (the founder of polyarchy) advocates for a conjunction of [[File:Cosmo.png]] [[cosmopolitanism]] and [[File:Panarchy.png]] [[panarchism]].


== How to Draw ==
==How to Draw==


{{Flag|Panarchy_flag.svg}}
{{Flag|Panarchy_flag.svg}}
Line 51: Line 81:
#Draw the eyes and you're done!
#Draw the eyes and you're done!
{{Flag-auto
{{Flag-auto
|c1 = Black
|c1=Black
|h1 = #141414
|h1=#141414
|c2 = Yellow
|c2=Yellow
|h2 = #E7E700
|h2=#E7E700
}}
}}


== Relations ==
==Relations==
=== Friends ===
===Friends===
*[[File:Autarch.png]] [[Autarchism]] - Rule of self!
*[[File:Autarch.png]] [[Autarchy]] - Rule of self!
*[[File:Ancap-0.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism]] - Wonderful ideas, but you treat moving light-headedly.
*[[File:Ancap-0.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism]] - Wonderful ideas, but you treat moving light-headedly.
*[[File:Hoppef.png]] [[Hoppeanism]] - Your covenants are a great idea.
*[[File:Hoppef.png]] [[Hoppeanism]] - Your covenants are a great idea.
*[[File:Anmona.png]] [[Anarcho-Monarchism]] - Best monarchist.
*[[File:Anmona.png]] [[Anarcho-Monarchism]] - Best monarchist.
*[[File:Natan.png]] [[National Anarchism]] - Best nationalist.
*[[File:Anfashf.png]] [[Anarcho-Fascism]] [[File:Anarcho-Fascismalt.png]] [[File:Jackanfash.png]] - The most tolerable member of his family.
*[[File:Anfashf.png]] [[Anarcho-Fascism]] [[File:Anarcho-Fascismalt.png]] [[File:Jackanfash.png]] - The most tolerable member of his family.
*[[File:Optim.png]] [[Optimateism]] - It is strange to admit, but Rome had first polycentric law.


===Frenemies===
===Frenemies===


*[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]] - You are my main inspiration though the social contract is BS. If we get to compromise on a Classical Liberalism closer to [[File:Austrobert.png]] [[Austrolibertarianism|Mises's]], we might get to an agreement.<ref>[https://mises.org/library/mises-secession Mises on secession]</ref>
*[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]] - You are my main inspiration though the social contract is BS. If we get to compromise on a Classical Liberalism closer to [[File:Austrobert.png]] [[Austrian School|Mises's]], we might get to an agreement.<ref>[https://mises.org/library/mises-secession Mises on secession]</ref>
*[[File:Irridentism.png]] [[Irredentism]] - Depends. If you restore connection after it was forcibly broken by war - it's good, but if people there don't want to be part of your country, then not.
*[[File:Irridentism.png]] [[Irredentism]] - Depends. If you restore connection after it was forcibly broken by war - it's good, but if people there don't want to be part of your country, then not.
*[[File:Synthesisanarchy.png]] [[Synthesis Anarchism]] - We can make a good team if you drop your anti-capitalism.
*[[File:Synthesisanarchy.png]] [[Synthesis Anarchism]] - We can make a good team if you drop your anti-capitalism.
*[[File:Urb.png]] [[Urbism]] - Every city is a state? How about every individual?
*[[File:Urb.png]] [[Patchwork]] - Every city is a state? How about every individual?
*[[File:Mutalist.png]] [[Mutualism]] - Against territorial monopoly just like me, but why limit yourself to only one economical system?
*[[File:Mutalist.png]] [[Mutualism]] - Against territorial monopoly just like me, but why limit yourself to only one economical system?
*[[File:Meta-Anarchism.png]] [[Post-Anarchism|Meta-Anarchism]] - Often people confuse us, he says some takes I can agree with tho.
*[[File:Meta-Anarchism.png]] [[Nomadology]] - Often people confuse us, he says some takes I can agree with tho.
*[[File:Demcon.png]] [[Democratic Confederalism]] - Based, but I wish you were more open to markets.


===Enemies===
===Enemies===
Line 78: Line 111:
*[[File:imp.png]] [[Imperialism]] - You want to force people to live with the government they don't want to be part of.
*[[File:imp.png]] [[Imperialism]] - You want to force people to live with the government they don't want to be part of.
*[[File:Illum.png]] [[Illuminatism]] - Wet dream of that guy above.
*[[File:Illum.png]] [[Illuminatism]] - Wet dream of that guy above.
*[[File:Unimon.png]] [[Universal Monarchism]] - Again?
*[[File:World_Federalism2.png]] [[World Federalism]] - Any system will corrupt, if it happens localy, people can atleast leave to somewhere safe, if global government will corrupt, there will be no hope for them.
*[[File:World.png]] [[Globalism]] & [[File:World_Federalism2.png]] [[World Federalism]] - Any system will corrupt, if it happens localy, people can atleast leave to somewhere safe, if global government will corrupt, there will be no hope for them.
*[[File:Ultranat.png]] [[Ultranationalism]] - Whatever you say it makes absolutely no sense to me.
*[[File:Ultranat.png]] [[Ultranationalism]] - Whatever you say it makes absolutely no sense to me.


Line 85: Line 119:


*[http://panarchy.org/indexes/panarchy.html Most of the Panarchy related literature ]
*[http://panarchy.org/indexes/panarchy.html Most of the Panarchy related literature ]
*[https://mises.org/es/library/nations-consent-decomposing-nation-state-0 Nations By Consent: Decomposing the Nation-State] by [[File:Rothbard.png]] [[w:Murray N. Rothbard|Murray N. Rothbard]]
*[https://mises.org/es/library/nations-consent-decomposing-nation-state-0 Nations By Consent: Decomposing the Nation-State] by [[File:Murray N Rothbard.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Murray N. Rothbard]]
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20110225024300/http://osf1.gmu.edu/~ihs/w91issues.html Polycentric Law] by Tom W. Bell


===Wikipedia===
===Wikipedia===
Line 97: Line 132:


==Gallery==
==Gallery==
===Portraits===
<gallery>
<gallery>
⚫
Legend2T-8X8.png|Credit: [[File:Colmin.png]][[TheLegend2T]], [https://www.reddit.com/r/Polcompballanarchy/comments/mxw8js/the_8x8_anarchist_compass/ Source]
Pan.png
Pan.png
Panarchyball.png|alt design
Panarchyball.png|Legacy design
File:Polyarchy Countryball.jpeg|Polyarchy
</gallery>
</gallery>


====Alternative designs====
⚫
==Navigation==
<gallery>
{{libright}}
PolyarchyPolyarchy.png|Polyarchy
{{Anarchist}}
</gallery>
{{Libertarian}}


===Comics and Artwork===
<gallery mode="slideshow">
⚫
Legend2T-8X8.png|Credit: [[File:Colmin.png]][[User:TheLegend2T|TheLegend2T]], [https://www.reddit.com/r/Polcompballanarchy/comments/mxw8js/the_8x8_anarchist_compass/ Source]
</gallery>

⚫
==Navigation==
{{Navbox/Libright}}
{{Navbox/Anarchists}}
{{Navbox/Capitalists}}
{{Navbox/Liberals}}
{{Navbox/Libertarians}}
[[Category:Libertarian Unity]]
[[Category:Libertarian Unity]]
[[Category:Government Systems]]
[[Category:Government Systems]]
[[Category:Libertarians]]

Latest revision as of 14:48, 4 March 2024

"In our system there will be no more expensive balancing acts or catastrophic downfalls; no more conspiracies or usurpations. Everybody is legitimate and nobody. One remains legitimate without objection as long as one is accepted, and for one's supporters alone. Apart from this, there will be neither divine nor secular rights, no right except that to change, to perfect one's program and to make fresh appeals to one's followers."

Panarchism is an ideology that believes that the populace should have the right to choose the form of government ( or lack thereof) that they are part of/live under without having to change their physical residence.
It's the idea that every part of a certain country or group of lands should be led by voluntary associations of people and free competition of form of governments, similar to the competition of private firms on the market. People could associate and disassociate from different governments depending on their preferences.
De Puydt, being a classical liberal, favored Laissez-Faire economics, but Panarchism allows for different economic systems to co-exist.
Conflicts between people, that are part of different governments (or no government), would be handled by third-party judges and would lead to a standardization of law (like common law) among everyone as continuous conflict resolution takes place, similar to how anarcho-capitalists envision private law societies.

History

Paul E. De Puydt, the founder of Panarchism, was a Belgian writer of the 19th century. He devised Panarchism in the year 1860 with an article with the same name[1] which was influenced by his ideas of free competition (result of his support for free market liberalism) as well as his fellow Belgian economist, Gustave de Molinari, who also believed the principles of free competition in the market should be expanded upon previously considered "public matters".
De Puydt, seeing how constant infighting over forms of government affected Europe in the 19th century, realized that it was impossible to please everyone by forcing them under a singular system, but rather the way to end these conflicts was to give everyone the chance to choose their ideal form of governance, and not interfere with that of others in a similar manner to how a Prussian citizen has no business in the governance of France.
Though De Puydt's ideas never succeded, its influence can be seen in the writings of other Clasical Liberal writers such as Auberon Herbert, Anarchist writers such as Anselme Bellegarrigue and Max Nettlau, as well as many modern Anarcho-Capitalist thinkers, who argue that it approximated polycentric law.

Variants

Polyarchy

Flag of Polyarchy

Polyarchy is an economically variable, libertarian ideology, that strives to create a society based on voluntaryism, pluralism and spatialism. To achieve this society, Gian Piero de Bellis (the founder of polyarchy) advocates for a conjunction of cosmopolitanism and panarchism.

How to Draw

Flag of Panarchism
  1. Draw a ball,
  2. Divide it into quadrants,
  3. Colour the top right and bottom left quadrants a lighter shade of black,
  4. Draw a yellow infinity sign,
  5. Draw the eyes and you're done!
Color Name HEX RGB
Black #141414 20, 20, 20
Yellow #E7E700 231, 231, 0


Relations

Friends

Frenemies

  • Classical Liberalism - You are my main inspiration though the social contract is BS. If we get to compromise on a Classical Liberalism closer to Mises's, we might get to an agreement.[2]
  • Irredentism - Depends. If you restore connection after it was forcibly broken by war - it's good, but if people there don't want to be part of your country, then not.
  • Synthesis Anarchism - We can make a good team if you drop your anti-capitalism.
  • Patchwork - Every city is a state? How about every individual?
  • Mutualism - Against territorial monopoly just like me, but why limit yourself to only one economical system?
  • Nomadology - Often people confuse us, he says some takes I can agree with tho.
  • Democratic Confederalism - Based, but I wish you were more open to markets.

Enemies

  • Imperialism - You want to force people to live with the government they don't want to be part of.
  • Illuminatism - Wet dream of that guy above.
  • Universal Monarchism - Again?
  • Globalism & World Federalism - Any system will corrupt, if it happens localy, people can atleast leave to somewhere safe, if global government will corrupt, there will be no hope for them.
  • Ultranationalism - Whatever you say it makes absolutely no sense to me.

Further Reading

Literature

Wikipedia

References

  1. ↑ Panarchism by Paul Émile de Puydt (1860)
  2. ↑ Mises on secession

2. http://panarchy.org/

Gallery

Portraits

  • Legacy design

    Legacy design

Alternative designs

  • Polyarchy

    Polyarchy

Comics and Artwork

Navigation

Retrieved from "https://polcompball.wiki/wiki/Panarchism?oldid=502863"