Minarcho-Socialism: Difference between revisions
Antonio 1555 (talk | contribs) I added more information |
No edit summary |
||
(136 intermediate revisions by 35 users not shown) | |||
Line 1:
{{MessageBox/Stub}}
{{Ideology
|themecolor=#141414
|textcolor=#ff0000
|
|image=Minarcho-Socialism-Chara-Portrait.png
|caption="No more ‘socialist’ tyrants!"
|aliases={{ScrollBox|
[[File:
Left-Minarchism<br>
Decentralist Socialism<br>
[[File:Mincomball-icon.png]] {{PCBA|Minarcho-Communism}} (Some)
}}
|alignments=
{{Info|Libertarian Left|LibLeft}}<br>
{{Info|Culturally Left}}<br>
{{Info|Socialists}}<br>
[[File:Commie.png|link=:Category:Communists]] [[:Category:Communists|{{Color|#B00000|'''Communists'''}}]] (Some)<br> [[File:QuasiCommie.png|link=Quasi-Communism (Disambiguation)]] [[:Quasi-Communism (Disambiguation)|{{Color|#8B0000|'''Quasi-Communists'''}}]] (Except For The Fully Communist Variants) <br>
[[File:LeftBert.png|link=:Category:Libertarians]] [[:Category:Libertarians|{{Color|#FF0000|'''Libertarians'''}}]]<br>
[[File:Mincomball-icon.png]] [[:Category:Minarchists|{{Color|#0000FF|'''Minarchists'''}}]]<br>
{{Info|Democratic}}<br>
|theorists=
[[File:PanAmer.png]] '''Americas''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:MurrayBookchin.png]] [[Libertarian Municipalism|Murray Bookchin]] (1921-2006) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
}}
[[File:Cball-Commonwealth.png]] '''Commonwealth Realm''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:Philan.png]] [[Philosophical Anarchism|Peter Marshall]] (1946-) [[File:Cball-UK.png]] {{PBW|UKball|UK}}
*[[File:Demsocstar.png]] [[Democratic Socialism|Peter Hain]] (1950-) [[File:Cball-UK.png]] {{PBW|UKball|UK}}
}}
[[File:Cball-EU.png]] '''Europe''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:Minmut.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism|Francesc Pi i Margall]] (1824-1901) [[File:Cball-Spain.png]] {{PBW|Spainball|Spain}}
*[[File:Einstein.png]] [[Scientocracy|Albert Einstein]] (1879-1955) [[File:Cball-GermanEmpire.png]] {{PBW|Germanyball|Germany}}
}}
[[File:PanAsian.png]] '''Asia''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:Demcon.png]] [[Democratic Confederalism|Abdullah Öcalan]] (1949-) [[File:Ottoman.png]] {{PBW|Turkeyball|Turkey}}
}}
|school =
|personal =
[[File:Mincomball-icon.png]] '''Lordon-Friot Communism''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:Directdem.png]] [[Democracy#Direct_Democracy|Direct Democracy]]
*[[File:Ecosoc.png]] [[Eco-Socialism]]
*[[File:Fed.png]] [[Federalism]]
*[[File:Bckchn.png]] [[Libertarian Municipalism]]
*[[File:Marketsoc.png]] [[Market Socialism]]
*[[File:Ormarxf.png]] [[Marxism]]
}}
|regional=
|influences=<div style="overflow:auto; height:auto; max-height:200px; background:transparent;">
[[File:Minarchist.png]] [[Minarchism]]<br>
[[File:Libsoc.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism]]<br>
</div>
|influenced=
<div style="overflow:auto; height:auto; max-height:200px; background:transparent;">
[[File:Einstein.png]] [[Scientocracy|Einsteinism]]<br>
[[File:Zapa.png]] [[Neozapatismo]]<br>
[[File:Norf.png]] [[Separatism|Northumbrian Independence]]<br>
[[File:UKPlaid.png]] [[Left-Wing Nationalism|Plaid Cymru]]<br>
</div>
|examples=
[[File:Rojava.png]] [[Democratic Confederalism|Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria (Rojava)]] (2012-)<br>
|song=
|likes=
Minimal governance<br>
[[File:Soc-h.png]] Socialism<br>
|dislikes=
People thinking that Rojava is anarchist<br>
}}
{{Quote|
quote="While council communism and Luxembourgism largely remain obscure and irrelevant tendencies in modern political organizing, especially in the so-called united states, we can look towards the autonomous territory of Rojava and groups in the so-called united states such as the Green Party, Democratic Socialists of America, Our Revolution, Justice Democrats, and the Democratic Freedom Caucus for examples of left minarchism in action."
|speaker=[[File:Anarchristian.png]] [[Christian Anarchism|Logan Marie Glitterbomb]]
}}
'''{{PAGENAME}}''', also known by the abbreviation '''MinSoc''', is a generally culturally progressive, libertarian left ideology that seeks to combine worker owned means of production with an "as minimal as possible" state to ensure the protection of workers and their rights.
==History==
==Personality==
Minarcho-Socialism usually acts as [[File:Ancom.png]] [[Anarcho-Communism]]'s wise and pragmatic sibling, mirroring the relationship between [[File:Minarchist.png]] [[Minarchism]] and [[File:Ancapf.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism]]. It can also be depicted as a boring version of Anarcho-Communism.
==Beliefs==
==Variants==
===[[File:Mincomball-icon.png]] Lordon-Friot Communism===
The political proposition formulated by french economists [[File:Neomarx.png]] Frédéric Lordon and [[File:Christcom.png]] Bernard Friot, while they do not use the term Minarcho-Socialism to describe it, and explicitly state it as communist, could be a form of minarchism as a way to establish communism or socialism. They advocate for a shift in the conception of salary, to change it from its capitalist form into a form of communist salary, explained mainly in Friot's work as "unconditional lifelong salary". This salary would be entitled to a person on the base of its irrevocable qualification as a productive agent, thus making a difference between work and employment. It essentially consists of paying a first level of salary to all citizens entering civil majority, by socializing the wealth produced through the social contribution to collective salary funds. The salary would thus no longer be linked to the job, property of the employer, but to a political status of the producer attached to the person. It would also allow recognition to a part of the non-market GDP, such as domestic work, the activity of retirees, the unemployed, volunteers, students, etc. all activities previously considered as free services and not producing economic value. This change in the social balance of production should, according to Lordon, be implemented through the establishment of a communist state - as opposed to the current capitalist state - which he describes as "an extremely federal structure [...] applying a principle of maximum subsidiarity, by devolution of the greatest possible autonomy to the most local levels possible".<ref>[https://youtu.be/dWe0m9ua7TM?t=4159], Youtube.com.</ref>
==How To Draw==
Line 34 ⟶ 91:
#Draw a ball.
#Color the ball black.
#Draw a red gear in the
#Draw a red star in the middle of the gear.
#Add the eyes
You are done!
{{Flag-auto
|c1
|h1
|c2
|h2
}}
==Relationships==
===
*[[File:Libsoc.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism]] - My moderate best friend, who tends to emphasize a more direct form of democracy.
*[[File:
*[[File:
*[[File:Ancom.png|frameless]] [[Anarcho-Communism]] - My brother, he can be a little wacky sometimes, but I love him anyways.
*[[File:Liberalsoc.png]] [[Liberal Socialism]] - Fellow small government socialist, just a bit more moderate than me. <s>Though I would appreciate it if some of your [[File:SDA.png]][[File:AOC.png]][[File:Partito Socialista Italiano-icon.png]][[File:Kwaśniecki.png]] followers [[File:Huism.png]][[File:NCPA.png]] would stop being so moderate and willing to compromise with capitalism</s>
*[[File:Demcon.png]] [[Democratic Confederalism]] - I support you in Syria.
*[[File:World_Federalism2.png]] [[World Federalism]] - [[File:Einstein.png]] Einstein was based.
*[[File:Cybercr.png]] [[Cyberocracy]] - Automating a minimal state sounds very fascinating, and the development of such technologies could be aided by the socialist orientation of the economy.
*[[File:Soc-h.png]] [[Socialism]] - My economics. Also, I have to give thanks to Lassalle for coining the term “night-watchman state,” even if it was in a pejorative sense.
===Frenemies===
*[[File:Minarchist.png]] [[Minarchism]] - We agree on the civic axis, but can you stop simping for [[File:Cap.png]] [[Capitalism]]?
*[[File:Crusade of Romanianism.png]] [[Crusade of Romanianism]] - Me, but... ultranationalist?
*[[File:Leftnat.png]] [[Left-Wing Nationalism]] - Can be too statist, but [[File:IrishRepublican.png]] Éire Nua is quite based.
*[[File:Baath.png]] [[Ba'athism]] - Totalitarian state capitalist, but thanks for allying with my [[File:Demcon.png]] [[Democratic Confederalism|friend]].
*[[File:Libpos.png]] [[Libertarian Possibilism]] - I admire your vision of weakening strong state power, but why do you want to get rid of the state entirely? Also how can you possibly achieve this with minor reforms within the system?
===Enemies===
*[[File:Authcap.png]] [[Authoritarian Capitalism]] - Authoritarian AND capitalist? No thanks!
*[[File:Statesoc.png]] [[State Socialism]] - NO YOU DUMBA**!!! SOCIALISM IS '''NOT''' WHEN THE GOVERNMENT DOES STUFF!!!
*[[File:Avar.png]] [[Avaritionism]] - You are kinda right when you say that the stateless socialists advocate for a state without a state. You are still just a psychopathic capitalist interested only in deriving a profit from killing people.
*[[File:Ottoman.png]] [[Neo-Ottomanism]] - Get out of Rojava, you authoritarian, anti-socialist, imperialist scum!!
*[[File:Nazi.png]] [[Nazism]] - Darwinist a**hole whose anti-semitic atrocities forced Einstein to leave Germany.
==Gallery==
===Portraits===
<gallery>
Minarcho-Socialism.png
Minarchosocialism.png
Minasoc.jpeg
</gallery>
==Further Information==
===Columns===
*[https://c4ss.org/content/52937 Demystifying Left Minarchism] by [[File:Anarchristian.png]] [[Christian Anarchism|Logan Marie Glitterbomb]]
*[https://repeaterbooks.com/product/against-the-law-why-justice-requires-fewer-laws-and-a-smaller-state/ Against the Law: Why Justice Requires Fewer Laws and a Smaller State] by David Renton
*[https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/logan-marie-glitterbomb-constitutionalism-as-a-threat Constitutionalism As a Threat] by Logan Marie Glitterbomb
*[https://autonomies.org/2019/10/frederic-lordon-imagining-revolution-and-the-problem-of-scale/ Frédéric Lordon: Imagining Revolution and the Problem of Scale] by Julius Gavroche
===
<references />
==Navigation==
{{Navbox/Libleft}}
{{Navbox/Socialists}}
{{Navbox/Prefixes}}
[[Category:Culturally Left]]
[[Category:Minarchists]]
[[Category:Democratic]]
|
Latest revision as of 19:24, 7 August 2024
Not to be confused with
Monarcho-Socialism
"While council communism and Luxembourgism largely remain obscure and irrelevant tendencies in modern political organizing, especially in the so-called united states, we can look towards the autonomous territory of Rojava and groups in the so-called united states such as the Green Party, Democratic Socialists of America, Our Revolution, Justice Democrats, and the Democratic Freedom Caucus for examples of left minarchism in action."
Minarcho-Socialism, also known by the abbreviation MinSoc, is a generally culturally progressive, libertarian left ideology that seeks to combine worker owned means of production with an "as minimal as possible" state to ensure the protection of workers and their rights.
History
Personality
Minarcho-Socialism usually acts as Anarcho-Communism's wise and pragmatic sibling, mirroring the relationship between
Minarchism and
Anarcho-Capitalism. It can also be depicted as a boring version of Anarcho-Communism.
Beliefs
Minarcho-Socialism, like its right-libertarian counterpart, believes that the state should be kept as minimal as possible. Unlike regular Minarchism, Minarcho-Socialism advocates for a small state under a socialist or communist society, and may also believe in minimal state welfare services. The main difference between MinSoc and Libertarian Socialism is the prospect of the industry remaining separate from the government. Alternatively, Minarcho-Socialism can simply be viewed as a non-anarchist variant of
Libertarian Socialism.
Variants
Lordon-Friot Communism
The political proposition formulated by french economists Frédéric Lordon and
Bernard Friot, while they do not use the term Minarcho-Socialism to describe it, and explicitly state it as communist, could be a form of minarchism as a way to establish communism or socialism. They advocate for a shift in the conception of salary, to change it from its capitalist form into a form of communist salary, explained mainly in Friot's work as "unconditional lifelong salary". This salary would be entitled to a person on the base of its irrevocable qualification as a productive agent, thus making a difference between work and employment. It essentially consists of paying a first level of salary to all citizens entering civil majority, by socializing the wealth produced through the social contribution to collective salary funds. The salary would thus no longer be linked to the job, property of the employer, but to a political status of the producer attached to the person. It would also allow recognition to a part of the non-market GDP, such as domestic work, the activity of retirees, the unemployed, volunteers, students, etc. all activities previously considered as free services and not producing economic value. This change in the social balance of production should, according to Lordon, be implemented through the establishment of a communist state - as opposed to the current capitalist state - which he describes as "an extremely federal structure [...] applying a principle of maximum subsidiarity, by devolution of the greatest possible autonomy to the most local levels possible".[1]
How To Draw
- Draw a ball.
- Color the ball black.
- Draw a red gear in the center.
- Draw a red star in the middle of the gear.
- Add the eyes
You are done!
Color Name | HEX | RGB | |
---|---|---|---|
Black | #141414 | 20, 20, 20 | |
Red | #FF0000 | 255, 0, 0 |
Relationships
Friends
Libertarian Socialism - My moderate best friend, who tends to emphasize a more direct form of democracy.
Democratic Socialism - A bit statist, but there is much overlap between us.
Libertarian Municipalism - A friend who focuses on the environment.
Anarcho-Communism - My brother, he can be a little wacky sometimes, but I love him anyways.
Liberal Socialism - Fellow small government socialist, just a bit more moderate than me.
Though I would appreciate it if some of yourfollowers
would stop being so moderate and willing to compromise with capitalism
Democratic Confederalism - I support you in Syria.
World Federalism -
Einstein was based.
Cyberocracy - Automating a minimal state sounds very fascinating, and the development of such technologies could be aided by the socialist orientation of the economy.
Socialism - My economics. Also, I have to give thanks to Lassalle for coining the term “night-watchman state,” even if it was in a pejorative sense.
Frenemies
Minarchism - We agree on the civic axis, but can you stop simping for
Capitalism?
Crusade of Romanianism - Me, but... ultranationalist?
Left-Wing Nationalism - Can be too statist, but
Éire Nua is quite based.
Ba'athism - Totalitarian state capitalist, but thanks for allying with my
friend.
Libertarian Possibilism - I admire your vision of weakening strong state power, but why do you want to get rid of the state entirely? Also how can you possibly achieve this with minor reforms within the system?
Enemies
Authoritarian Capitalism - Authoritarian AND capitalist? No thanks!
State Socialism - NO YOU DUMBA**!!! SOCIALISM IS NOT WHEN THE GOVERNMENT DOES STUFF!!!
Avaritionism - You are kinda right when you say that the stateless socialists advocate for a state without a state. You are still just a psychopathic capitalist interested only in deriving a profit from killing people.
Neo-Ottomanism - Get out of Rojava, you authoritarian, anti-socialist, imperialist scum!!
Nazism - Darwinist a**hole whose anti-semitic atrocities forced Einstein to leave Germany.
Gallery
Portraits
Further Information
Columns
- Demystifying Left Minarchism by
Logan Marie Glitterbomb
- Against the Law: Why Justice Requires Fewer Laws and a Smaller State by David Renton
- Constitutionalism As a Threat by Logan Marie Glitterbomb
- Frédéric Lordon: Imagining Revolution and the Problem of Scale by Julius Gavroche